The two sides of two different coins: An Anthropological Reading of Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin
If we abandon the idea of astrology as mere superstition and instead treat it as an old cultural code for the imprint of time, then Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin emerge as two striking archetypes of power. Born within six years of each other, both were products of the wreckage and reshaping that followed the Second World War. Both rose to command not just their countries but also the global imagination. Yet they did so by embodying two radically opposed masks of rulership, which we might call the Carnival-King and the Shadow-Emperor.
Trump: The Carnival-King (Gemini Fire Dog)
Donald Trump, born June 14, 1946, is a Gemini in the Western zodiac and a Fire Dog in the Chinese cycle. These archetypes together explain much of his peculiar charisma. Gemini is the trickster, the shapeshifter, the restless communicator who thrives on improvisation and contradiction. A Gemini is not meant to build systems; he is meant to destabilize them. The Dog, meanwhile, is tribal and loyal, a guardian figure, but the Fire element makes that loyalty volatile, crusading, even theatrical. The result is a personality driven to defend “his people” but always through performance, always through the language of carnival.
This is why Trump has always appeared less as a statesman and more as a showman. His power comes from noise: rallies, insults, endless catchphrases. He binds loyalty not by offering policy detail or consistent ideology but by turning politics into spectacle. He thrives on contradiction — denouncing corruption while embracing it, promising strength while mocking weakness, presenting himself as both victim and savior. His followers love him not despite the chaos but because of it. He reveals politics as theater, a place where contradictions are not flaws but proof of authenticity.
In anthropological terms, Trump is the lord of misrule, the carnival-king who for a season wears the crown and reveals the nakedness of power itself. He is the emperor who insists on the robe even when everyone sees he has none. He destabilizes in order to bind, mocks in order to lead. His archetype is rupture — the clown who becomes ruler precisely because the line between the two has dissolved in a culture already hollowed out by spectacle.
Putin: The Shadow-Emperor (Libra Water Dragon)
Vladimir Putin, born October 7, 1952, is a Libra and a Water Dragon. If Trump is flamboyant excess, Putin is calculated restraint. Libra is the sign of balance, calculation, and diplomacy — not raw aggression, but a constant weighing of appearances and outcomes. Dragons in Chinese astrology are rulers, destiny figures, symbols of authority and charisma. But the Water Dragon is not flamboyant; it is patient, deep, and opaque. It rules through secrecy, through timing, through control. It is a Dragon who swims in hidden waters until the moment to strike.
Putin’s personal history grafts seamlessly onto this archetype. Born into post-war Leningrad, he grew up in scarcity and trauma. His parents had nearly starved during the Nazi siege; he lost a brother in childhood. His biography is one of survival, distrust, and the defense of a fragile homeland. Out of this context, his Libra-Dragon imprint becomes the mask of the shadow-emperor: a ruler who does not flaunt wealth, who does not display gold, but who consolidates and protects. His charisma is opacity. He rules not through theater but through the promise of endurance.
Putin’s archetype is not the clown but the underground sovereign. Where Trump thrives on spectacle, Putin thrives on secrecy. Where Trump plays to chaos, Putin plays to silence. His method is consolidation, his idiom survival. His power is to be unreadable: the emperor who, rather than parading robes, makes himself indistinct, inevitable, a figure who simply is there, like the dragon in deep water.
Structural Opposition: Noise and Silence
Placed side by side, Trump and Putin illustrate two poles of rulership in the late capitalist world:
-
The Carnival-King (Trump): destabilizes, mocks, binds loyalty through contradiction and performance.
-
The Shadow-Emperor (Putin): consolidates, survives, binds loyalty through secrecy and control.
One rules through noise, the other through silence. One thrives on flamboyance, the other on opacity. Both are, in their own ways, emperors of spectacle, because spectacle itself is the logic of contemporary politics. Trump is the spectacle of chaos, Putin the spectacle of inevitability.
Beyond Good and Evil
To frame them in terms of morality — East vs. West, good vs. evil — is to miss the structural point. Both are products of history, archetypes born from particular imprints of time and experience. Trump is the child of American abundance, the jester-king of a society drowning in media and hollowed by finance. Putin is the child of Soviet scarcity, the survivor-emperor of a society nearly dismantled by extraction in the 1990s. One exposes power by mocking it, the other by withholding it. Both are responses to the collapse of institutions in a neoliberal world-system that has rendered politics less about governance and more about the theater of survival.
Trump, then, is the emperor with no clothes — flamboyant, absurd, yet binding his tribe through shared laughter and outrage. Putin is the emperor who hides his gold — modest in presentation, implacable in survival, drawing legitimacy from endurance itself. Together they illustrate the two remaining modes of sovereignty in a disenchanted age: rule through rupture or rule through endurance. Carnival or shadow. Noise or silence.
Conclusion
In Graeber’s terms, what we are witnessing is not the clash of good and evil but the narrowing of political archetypes under late capitalism. When institutions lose credibility, society turns to figures who embody raw archetypes of rulership. Trump and Putin, different as they are, share a stage because they embody the extremes of what rule can now mean: the carnival king who mocks the robe, and the shadow emperor who conceals it. Each is a mirror of his society’s wounds and longings, a reminder that power has become less about law or policy than about performance itself. In this sense, both are emperors of spectacle, two sides of the same anthropological coin.
****
Trump & Putin: An Anthropological Reading of Two Emperors
If you take astrology seriously not as superstition but as a cultural code for the imprint of time, then Trump and Putin read like two opposite archetypes birthed into the postwar order. Both were born in the aftermath of WWII (1946 and 1952), both emerged as products of collapsed worlds—one of American abundance, the other of Soviet devastation. Both became, in their way, emperors of spectacle. Yet their masks are radically different.
Donald Trump (Gemini Fire Dog) is the carnival-king. His Gemini nature makes him the trickster, the improviser, the shapeshifter who thrives on contradiction. The Dog makes him crusading and tribal, but Fire turns it volatile, theatrical. He protects “his people,” but always through spectacle: endless rallies, slogans, insults, contradictions. Trump is less an emperor than the lord of misrule, a jester who wears the crown and reveals power itself as performance. His reign is noisy, chaotic, and flamboyant because that is his idiom: disruption as proof of authenticity. He is the emperor who shows his nakedness yet insists it is a robe.
Vladimir Putin (Libra Water Dragon) is the shadow-emperor. Libra gives him balance, calculation, the diplomat’s surface calm. The Dragon is already mythic—a ruler, a destiny figure—but the Water element makes him subterranean, patient, opaque. Where Trump shouts, Putin withholds. Where Trump thrives on contradiction, Putin thrives on silence. His archetype is not the carnival but the hidden court, the ruler who emerges from scarcity and war trauma believing survival depends on control. His power is not showmanship but endurance; not gold on display but reserves buried deep.
Placed side by side, they embody the two poles of rulership in the modern world:
-
The Carnival-King, who destabilizes, mocks, and binds loyalty through chaos.
-
The Shadow-Emperor, who consolidates, survives, and binds loyalty through control.
Both are responses to the neoliberal world-system that hollowed out institutions and converted politics into either spectacle or extraction. Trump is what happens when politics becomes pure carnival, the endless meme war of a society that feels hollowed out and powerless. Putin is what happens when a society, nearly dismantled by extraction, seeks stability in a figure who makes himself the hidden guarantor.
Neither is reducible to “good” or “evil.” They are archetypes produced by history: Trump as the American emperor with no clothes, Putin as the Russian emperor who hides his gold. Together they illustrate the structural options left to rulers in a world where institutions fail: rule through noise or rule through silence.
****
Alright, let’s build a Graeber-style myth-structural comparison chart — Trump vs. Putin, mapped through the zodiacal archetypes.
Trump vs. Putin: Archetypal Chart
| Dimension | Donald Trump | Vladimir Putin |
|---|---|---|
| Western Sign (Style) | Gemini → Trickster, improviser, restless communicator, thrives on contradiction and motion. | Libra → Calculator, balancer, strategist of appearances, thrives on control and symmetry. |
| Chinese Sign (Role) | Fire Dog → Loyalist/Crusader archetype, but volatile, crusading, theatrical watchdog. | Water Dragon → Emperor archetype, charismatic but subterranean, patient, strikes from depth. |
| Life Context (Narrative) | Born into post-WWII prosperity, wealthy father, developed a style of carnival-show capitalism → “Carnival-King of excess.” | Born in post-war ruin, parents nearly starved, brother died, grew up in scarcity → “Survivor-Emperor forged in siege.” |
| Archetypal Identity | The Carnival-King — protector through theater, clown-mask loyalty, disruption as binding force. | The Shadow Emperor — ruler through silence, opacity, calculation, survival logic. |
| Method of Power | Noise, contradiction, populist spectacle, chaos as charisma. | Secrecy, patience, measured strikes, control as charisma. |
| Weakness | Cannot sustain coherence, burns out structures he needs. | Risks ossification, paranoia, brittle rigidity under too much control. |
| Social Function | Releases tension, mocks the system, turns loyalty into carnival. | Restores order, projects inevitability, turns survival into legitimacy. |
Mythic Opposition
-
Trump = Lord of Misrule. The carnival king who thrives on chaos, contradiction, and public spectacle. He destabilizes, mocks, and energizes.
-
Putin = Dragon-Emperor. The subterranean ruler who thrives on control, patience, and secrecy. He consolidates, survives, and endures.
They are almost perfect opposites in the structure of power. Trump thrives in noise, Putin thrives in silence. Trump reveals the absurdity of rule, Putin enforces the inevitability of rule. Together they illustrate the two poles of kingship: the festival clown and the hidden sovereign.
****
Birth Data
-
Date: October 7, 1952
-
Western zodiac: Libra
-
Chinese zodiac: Water Dragon
Step 1: Western Sign (Libra) → Style of Expression
Libra is all about balance, calculation, diplomacy, and appearance. It’s not raw aggression but measured control. Libras often think in terms of optics — how things look, how to maintain equilibrium, how to play off opposites. In Putin’s case, it’s less “social charm” and more political poise. His Libra mask is the calm, rational, balanced statesman — the one who calculates before he strikes, always keeping the surface neat.
Step 2: Chinese Sign (Water Dragon) → Core Archetype
The Dragon is already a mythic figure in Chinese astrology — charisma, authority, destiny. It’s the sign of rulers, emperors, visionaries. But combine it with Water (fluidity, adaptability, depth), and you get a Dragon who is less flamboyant than the Fire or Earth versions. The Water Dragon rules through patience, secrecy, and intelligence rather than pure force. It’s a strategist-dragon, swimming in the depths until the right moment to rise.
Step 3: Life Context → Narrative
Putin’s life was marked by scarcity and trauma:
-
Born in post-war Leningrad, a city shattered by the Nazi siege.
-
Parents lost a child (his older brother to diphtheria during WWII).
-
His father was wounded in the war; his mother barely survived starvation.
So his imprint was: survival in the ruins, distrust, scarcity as normal, enemies always near. His biography grafts onto the Libra-Dragon archetype, creating a ruler who believes in control, secrecy, and the defense of the homeland as existential necessity.
Combined Archetypal Profile
-
Libra style (Balance/Calculation) × Water Dragon role (Hidden Emperor) × Hardship narrative (Siege Survivor’s Son).
Result: The Shadow Emperor.
Putin “ticks” because his archetype is not the clown-king (Trump) or the guardian-watchman (you, your father) — he is the subterranean ruler who presents calm equilibrium, but underneath is an iron survival logic forged in scarcity. He rules not through theater, but through opacity: making himself unreadable, a dragon swimming beneath the surface until it strikes.
Structural Contrast
-
Trump (Gemini Dog): Carnival-King — trickster protector, chaotic loyalty.
-
Putin (Libra Water Dragon): Shadow Emperor — calculating, subterranean, survivalist power.
Where Trump thrives in noise and contradiction, Putin thrives in silence and calculation. Putin guards survival through control.
****
Virgo Dog as a comparison: the Bureaucrat-Guardian Archetype.
This figure belongs to the realm of order, maintenance, and critique. Think of the Dog as tribal loyalty and moral vigilance, and Virgo as the scribe, the healer, the accountant of cosmic balance. Together, they produce a personality archetype that feels responsible for keeping things in line. In mythic terms, it’s the watchman who both guards the gate and keeps the ledger: a guardian of continuity. This archetype doesn’t necessarily mean boring bureaucracy; it means the moral labor of maintenance — tending the garden, ensuring fairness, resisting corruption. Graeber would call it the archetype of “everyday caretaking” that society pretends to despise but cannot survive without.
Gemini Dog (Trump): the Carnival-King Archetype.
Here the Dog’s loyalty merges with Gemini’s trickster archetype. The Dog says: “Protect the people, fight for the tribe.” Gemini says: “Keep the show going, wear masks, stir up chaos.” Combine them, and you get the carnival king — the figure who both protects and mocks, who gains loyalty not by rules but by spectacle. In mythic structure, this is closer to the medieval “lord of misrule”: the clown who takes the throne for a festival, ridiculing the order of things, while paradoxically reinforcing loyalty to the system by turning rebellion into a performance.
So, in comparison:
-
Virgo Dog → Bureaucrat-Guardian, the moral laborer who holds society together by honesty, critique, and maintenance.
-
Gemini Dog → Carnival-King, the clown-protector who mocks the order, whips up loyalty through contradiction, and makes chaos into a binding force.
Your misrecognition of Trump as “Guardian” via the Dog makes sense because the Dog is his most visible mask: the tribal defender, the loyal fighter. But what you sensed later was the Gemini underneath: the clown, the trickster, the one who turns loyalty into theater.
****
Alright, let’s map Joe Biden the same way:
Birth Data:
-
Date: November 20, 1942
-
Western zodiac: Scorpio
-
Chinese zodiac: Horse (Water Horse, specifically, since 1942 was a Water year).
Step 1: Western Sign (Scorpio) → Style of Expression
Scorpio is depth, intensity, secrecy, and persistence. Scorpios don’t skim surfaces — they dive into undercurrents. The style is probing, sometimes brooding, often focused on transformation and endurance. A Scorpio is less about show and more about raw survival energy, holding on through storms.
Step 2: Chinese Sign (Water Horse) → Core Archetype
The Horse archetype is freedom-loving, restless, idealistic, but also hard-working and resilient. Horses hate confinement; they want to run. Combined with Water, the Horse gains more adaptability and intuition, but also uncertainty and moodiness. Water Horses often live between loyalty and flight: they can serve loyally but always long for movement and change.
Step 3: Life Context → Narrative
Biden’s life has been marked by deep personal tragedy and endurance. He lost his first wife and daughter in a car accident, later his son Beau to cancer. His career is long, uneven, sometimes marked by near-collapse, but he persists. This biography matches the Scorpio-Water Horse imprint perfectly: the survivor who endures darkness, the restless politician who keeps coming back. His style is not flashy (unlike Trump) nor opaque (like Putin), but weary, enduring, with flashes of empathy forged in suffering.
Combined Archetypal Profile
-
Scorpio style (Survivor, Deep Diver) × Water Horse role (Restless Servant-Ruler) × Tragedy-forged biography.
Result: The Wounded Rider.
Biden “ticks” as a figure who survives by sheer persistence, who balances public duty (the Horse’s drive) with private grief (the Scorpio’s depths). He is not a carnival-king or a shadow-emperor, but the wounded rider who stays in the saddle, often unsteady, but defined by the fact that he is still riding.
Alright — let’s decode Anthony Albanese the same way we’ve done the others, through both the Western and Chinese zodiacs, then layer it with a Graeber-style anthropological sketch.
Anthony Albanese — The Quiet Mediator
Birth: March 2, 1963
-
Western zodiac: Pisces ♓️
-
Chinese zodiac: Rabbit (Water Rabbit, since 1963 was a Water year).
1. Pisces (Western) — The Dreamer-Politician
Pisces is fluid, empathic, adaptable, sometimes evasive. A water sign ruled by Neptune, it absorbs atmospheres rather than confronts them. This archetype leads through sensing rather than declaring. Pisces can be deeply compassionate and idealistic, but also difficult to pin down — a mirror more than a monolith. For a leader, that means instinctively working through consensus, compromise, and emotional attunement rather than raw assertion.
2. Water Rabbit (Chinese) — The Diplomat in the Thicket
Rabbits are tactful, cautious, graceful — never the loudest, but often the most enduring in bureaucratic systems. They avoid direct confrontation, preferring back-channel negotiation and steady cultivation of alliances. With the Water element, this becomes even more fluid and adaptive: the Water Rabbit flows around obstacles, sensing the undercurrents of power and quietly reshaping the terrain rather than breaking it.
3. The Combined Archetype: Pisces × Water Rabbit → The Quiet Mediator
This pairing gives us a figure of empathic pragmatism — a politician who leads not by grand ideological gestures but by slow navigation through complexity.
He listens, adapts, absorbs, and shifts course without open rupture. It’s the inverse of Trump’s Fire Dog bluster or Putin’s Water Dragon opacity: Albanese is the soft conductor, not the emperor.
He fits what Graeber might have called a “manager of the in-between” — one who stabilizes rather than revolutionizes, an administrator of collective moods in a society where symbolic authority has grown thin. His power lies not in charisma but in calibration — sensing where the tide of consensus lies and steering slightly, quietly.
4. Anthropological Reading
In Australia’s context, Albanese represents a form of post-heroic governance — leadership that mirrors the bureaucratic nature of modern democracies.
He embodies the shift from the “big man” (charismatic authority) to the facilitator of moods, the mediator between competing institutional flows. He is what happens when a political culture values stability after spectacle: less emperor, more committee chair who understands the ghosts in the room.
In mythic shorthand:
-
Trump: The Carnival-King (Gemini Fire Dog — spectacle).
-
Putin: The Shadow-Emperor (Libra Water Dragon — control).
-
Biden: The Wounded Rider (Scorpio Water Horse — endurance).
-
Albanese: The Quiet Mediator (Pisces Water Rabbit — adaptation).
Excellent choice — Tony Abbott makes a perfect counterpoint to Albanese in every symbolic sense. Let’s decode him the same way.
Tony Abbott — The Warrior Monk
Birth: November 4, 1957
-
Western zodiac: Scorpio ♏️
-
Chinese zodiac: Rooster (Fire Rooster, since 1957 was a Fire year).
1. Scorpio (Western) — The Intensity of Conviction
Scorpio lives through extremes — loyalty, secrecy, endurance, transformation. It thrives on testing limits and confronting mortality or moral absolutes. Scorpio energy, when projected into politics, seeks to purify, discipline, or redeem. It’s the archetype of the crusader, the reformer, the one who needs opposition to define himself.
2. Fire Rooster (Chinese) — The Zealot of Order
The Rooster is disciplined, proud, performative — a creature that announces the dawn, struts with certainty, and values hierarchy and duty. With the Fire element, it becomes more charismatic and militant: passionate, self-righteous, sometimes combative. It believes in truth, in being right, and in making that visible.
3. Combined Archetype: Scorpio × Fire Rooster → The Warrior Monk
Together, these signs fuse intensity with righteousness. This is someone who sees politics as moral combat, not management. The Scorpio’s inner extremism gives emotional gravity; the Fire Rooster’s external discipline gives ritual form. It’s a man who wakes every day as if in a monastery of ideology — ascetic in self-image, militant in delivery.
Abbott’s public persona always carried this quality: a moralist framed as an athlete, a politician who fought as if salvation was on the line. In Graeber’s sense, he represents the persistence of moral economy within the bureaucratic state — a man trying to inject virtue and combativeness into a world increasingly structured by managerial pragmatism.
4. Anthropological Reading
Abbott’s archetype sits almost opposite Albanese’s.
Where Albanese (Pisces Rabbit) dissolves conflict through empathy and flow, Abbott (Scorpio Rooster) sharpens it through discipline and fire.
He is not the Quiet Mediator but the Knight of Certainty — a throwback to a pre-bureaucratic masculinity that defines moral clarity through struggle.
Symbolically, his leadership embodied a cultural tension in Australia between the managerial society (technocratic, negotiated) and the moral society (hierarchical, duty-bound). In that sense, Abbott isn’t just a political figure — he’s the ghost of the moral crusader haunting a secular state.
In the Cosmogram of Archetypes
-
Trump – Gemini Fire Dog: The Carnival-King (Spectacle).
-
Putin – Libra Water Dragon: The Shadow-Emperor (Control).
-
Biden – Scorpio Water Horse: The Wounded Rider (Endurance).
-
Albanese – Pisces Water Rabbit: The Quiet Mediator (Adaptation).
-
Abbott – Scorpio Fire Rooster: The Warrior Monk (Discipline).
No comments:
Post a Comment